New York State

Hotels in Montauk And The Hamptons

59 properties in our New York State selection sit in Montauk and the Hamptons. Compared on review record, price reference and what the property itself offers.

What the selection looks like

Across 53 of the 59 properties in Montauk and the Hamptons, the August 2026 snapshot ran from $129 to $833 a night, with a median of $247. Treat those as reference points rather than rates you can book today. 6 had no usable price in the snapshot and are compared on location and review record alone.

Review scores here have a median of 8.8, and 47 of 59 sit at 8.5 or higher. We rank on a review score weighted by how many reviews it rests on, so a perfect score from a handful of stays does not outrank a strong score from thousands.

Within this set, 38 of the 59 list a pool, a far higher share than anything in the city selection; 21 list a pet-friendly policy; the mix is mostly 29 hotel, 12 resort, 9 bed and breakfast.

Quick picks

Three worth starting with

Best overall record

The 1708 House

Highest review record in this shortlist once the number of reviews is taken into account.

9.6 out of 10 from 172 reviews

Best value

Aqualina Inn Montauk

Strongest review record for the money inside this shortlist, at about $141 against a $247 median.

9.3 out of 10 from 375 reviews

Best upscale choice

The Roundtree, Amagansett

The top of this shortlist on price, at about $833 a night in the snapshot.

9.4 out of 10 from 32 reviews

Comparison

Compare the shortlist

Our Montauk and the Hamptons selection, sortable by any column.
Hotel	Review score	Reviews	Price reference	Area	Best for	Book
The 1708 House	9.6	172	About $311	Montauk / Hamptons	Top rated	Check availability
Aria & Mare Hamptons	9.6	147	About $399	Montauk / Hamptons	Small property	Check availability
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach	9.7	46	About $222	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows	9.5	81	About $223	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Aqualina Inn Montauk	9.3	375	About $141	Montauk / Hamptons	Value for money	Check availability
Hotel Moraine	9.5	53	About $396	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
The Pridwin Hotel	9.4	79	About $499	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
The Menhaden Hotel	9.2	122	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast	9.8	19	About $482	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort	9.2	142	About $223	Montauk / Hamptons	Travel Proud	Check availability
Colonial Shores Resort	9.2	119	About $257	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
The Roundtree, Amagansett	9.4	32	About $833	Montauk / Hamptons	Luxury	Check availability
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk	9.1	194	About $332	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Driftwood Resort on the Ocean	9.1	104	About $191	Montauk / Hamptons	Value for money	Check availability
Montauk Manor	8.9	1,548	About $212	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Sea Crest	8.9	294	About $205	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Montauk Yacht Club	8.9	170	About $247	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
American Beech Hotel	8.9	163	About $239	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Beach Plum Resort	8.9	145	About $198	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Townhouses & Captain's Quarters	9.2	4	About $384	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Canoe Place Inn & Cottages	9.0	8	About $526	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
West Neck Guesthouse	8.9	17	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Small property	Check availability
The Preston House and Hotel	8.7	71	About $255	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Montauk Blue Hotel	8.8	1,061	About $222	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
East Hampton House Resort	8.8	220	About $229	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Sun and Sound Montauk	8.8	166	About $243	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Ocean View Terrace	8.8	81	About $202	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
The Baker House 1650	8.8	31	About $542	Montauk / Hamptons	Small property	Check availability
Hampton Bays Hotel On Main	9.0	1	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
The Chequit	9.0	1	About $406	Montauk / Hamptons	Small property	Check availability
The Huntting Inn	8.8	22	About $546	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
The Hermitage at Napeague	8.7	68	About $226	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
The Bentley Hotel Southampton, part of JdV by Hyatt	8.7	107	About $188	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Baron's Cove	8.7	148	About $312	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
The Ocean Resort Inn	8.7	183	About $141	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast	8.6	22	About $505	Montauk / Hamptons	Small property	Check availability
Harpoon House	8.6	29	About $370	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
EHP Resort & Marina	8.6	34	About $393	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
The Montauk Beach House	8.6	54	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Daunts Albatross Motel	8.6	93	About $268	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Journey East Hampton	8.6	111	About $368	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Hotel Indigo East End by IHG	8.6	168	About $149	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites East End by IHG	8.6	252	About $143	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Ocean Vista Resort	8.6	378	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Mill House Inn	8.5	63	About $399	Montauk / Hamptons	Travel Proud	Check availability
Residence Inn by Marriott New York Long Island East End	8.5	206	About $135	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
The Harbor Front Inn	8.5	209	About $261	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
A Wave Inn - Montauk	8.4	231	About $216	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Windward Shores	8.3	128	About $201	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Marram	8.3	139	About $394	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
The Surf Club Resort	8.3	170	About $296	Montauk / Hamptons	Spa	Check availability
Southampton Inn	8.3	200	About $262	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Ocean Surf Resort	8.3	206	About $162	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Hamlet Inn	8.3	274	About $154	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Kenny's Tipperary Inn	8.2	794	About $153	Montauk / Hamptons	Travel Proud	Check availability
The Montauk Soundview	8.1	377	About $227	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Bay Watch Hotel and Marina	7.7	70	not usable	Montauk / Hamptons	Montauk and the Hamptons	Check availability
Sound View Greenport	7.9	226	About $294	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort	7.5	988	About $129	Montauk / Hamptons	Restaurant	Check availability

How we select hotels →

The shortlist in detail

The 1708 House

Best for the strongest overall record in this shortlist

9.6 / 10 (172 reviews)About $311 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
4-star listing
Bed and breakfast

Its 9.6 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 172 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $311 against a $247 median.

Choose this if you want the safest pick here and the price fits.

View hotel Check current rates

Aria & Mare Hamptons

Best for a smaller property instead of a large hotel

9.6 / 10 (147 reviews)About $399 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
3-star listing
Bed and breakfast

Its 9.6 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 147 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $399 against a $247 median.

The trade-off

It is one of the more expensive options here: about $399 against a $247 median for this shortlist.

Choose this if the balance of location and review record suits your plans better than the alternatives above.

View hotel Check current rates

Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach

Best for travelers who want a spa

9.7 / 10 (46 reviews)About $222 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$150 to $300
4-star listing
Bed and breakfast

Its 9.7 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 46 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. Its reference price is close to the middle of this shortlist.

The trade-off

The score is high but rests on 46 reviews, so it carries less weight than a similar score from a few thousand.

Choose this if a spa is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Best for travelers who want a restaurant on site

9.5 / 10 (81 reviews)About $223 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$150 to $300
4-star listing

Its 9.5 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 81 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. Its reference price is close to the middle of this shortlist.

The trade-off

The score is high but rests on 81 reviews, so it carries less weight than a similar score from a few thousand.

Choose this if a restaurant on site is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

Aqualina Inn Montauk

Best for value inside this shortlist

9.3 / 10 (375 reviews)About $141 per night, August 2026 snapshot

Under $150
3-star listing
Motel

Its 9.3 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 375 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. The $141 reference price is below the $247 median of this shortlist.

Choose this if you want the review record without the upper half of this price range.

View hotel Check current rates

Hotel Moraine

Best for travelers who want a spa

9.5 / 10 (53 reviews)About $396 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
4-star listing

Its 9.5 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 53 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $396 against a $247 median.

The trade-off

It is one of the more expensive options here: about $396 against a $247 median for this shortlist.

Choose this if a spa is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

The Pridwin Hotel

Best for travelers who want a spa

9.4 / 10 (79 reviews)About $499 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
4-star listing

Its 9.4 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 79 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $499 against a $247 median.

The trade-off

It is one of the more expensive options here: about $499 against a $247 median for this shortlist.

Choose this if a spa is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast

Best for travelers who want a spa

9.8 / 10 (19 reviews)About $482 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
4-star listing
Bed and breakfast

Its 9.8 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 19 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $482 against a $247 median.

The trade-off

It is one of the more expensive options here: about $482 against a $247 median for this shortlist.

Choose this if a spa is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort

Best for travelers who want a Travel Proud listing

9.2 / 10 (142 reviews)About $223 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$150 to $300
3-star listing
Motel

Its 9.2 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 142 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. Its reference price is close to the middle of this shortlist.

Choose this if a Travel Proud listing is one of the things that decides the booking for you.

View hotel Check current rates

The Menhaden Hotel

Best for staying inside Montauk and the Hamptons

9.2 / 10 (122 reviews)

4-star listing

Its 9.2 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 122 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area.

Choose this if the balance of location and review record suits your plans better than the alternatives above.

View hotel Check current rates

Colonial Shores Resort

Best for staying inside Montauk and the Hamptons

9.2 / 10 (119 reviews)About $257 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$150 to $300
3-star listing
Motel

Its 9.2 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 119 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. Its reference price is close to the middle of this shortlist.

Choose this if the balance of location and review record suits your plans better than the alternatives above.

View hotel Check current rates

The Roundtree, Amagansett

Best for the upscale end of this shortlist

9.4 / 10 (32 reviews)About $833 per night, August 2026 snapshot

$300 and up
5-star listing

Its 9.4 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 32 reviews. It sits in the Montauk / Hamptons area. It is priced above this shortlist, at about $833 against a $247 median.

The trade-off

It is one of the more expensive options here: about $833 against a $247 median for this shortlist.

Choose this if you are deliberately buying the top end of this shortlist.

View hotel Check current rates

Written up in detail: the 12 strongest of 59. The comparison table above holds every one of them, and it sorts and filters.

Hotel data from a August 2026 source snapshot. Prices are reference points, not live rates.

FAQ

Common questions

How many properties does this page cover?

59 in our selection for Montauk and the Hamptons, and all of them are on this page.

Are the prices current?

No. Every figure is a reference point from our August 2026 snapshot.