Guest House

West Neck Guesthouse: Is It Right for Your Stay?

Ranked 22 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area on our weighted review measure.

Best for
A smaller property instead of a large hotel
Location
Montauk / Hamptons
Review score
8.9 out of 10 from 17 reviews
Price band
Not usable in the snapshot
Property type
Guest House, 2-star listing
Last checked
August 2026
Check current ratesCompare the area

The verdict

West Neck Guesthouse ranks 22 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area on our weighted review measure, which balances the score against the number of reviews behind it. It holds 8.9 out of 10 from 17 reviews. The clearest reason to shortlist it is a smaller property instead of a large hotel.

Its 8.9 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 17 reviews.

Location

The address is 31 West Neck Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, United States.

Streets and transit around West Neck GuesthouseNorth Ferry RoadGrand AvenueShore RoadSmith StreetMidway RoadManhanset RoadBayshore RoadWinthrop RoadNostrand ParkwayRocky Point RoadManwaring RoadWestmoreland DriveThis hotel0.5 milesN
Roads around the property and the nearby places where this shortlist has hotels, drawn to scale from OpenStreetMap. Distances are straight lines, not driving routes.

The honest comparison

Right for you or not

Book it if
  • travellers who want a solid middle option in the Montauk / Hamptons area
Look elsewhere if
  • A pool is part of your requirement: this property does not list one.
  • You want a well-tested property: this score rests on 17 reviews.

What the listing records

Facilities in the source listing

Recorded without a verification flag.

  • Free wifi
  • Children welcome

Related routes

Compare with other stays

Compare the whole regionRegionCompare the whole regionMontauk / HamptonsAll regionsNew York StateAll regionsThe second layer, outside the city

FAQ

Common questions

Is West Neck Guesthouse a good choice?

It depends on the trip. On our weighted review measure it ranks 22 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area. We found no measurable drawback against that comparison set.

What does it cost?

The snapshot holds no usable nightly price for this property, so we do not quote one.