Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel: Is It Right for Your Stay?
Ranked 7 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area on our weighted review measure.
- Best for
- Travelers who want a spa
- Location
- Montauk / Hamptons
- Review score
- 9.4 out of 10 from 79 reviews
- Price band
- $300 and up
- Property type
- Hotel, 4-star listing
- Last checked
- August 2026
The verdict
The Pridwin Hotel ranks 7 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area on our weighted review measure, which balances the score against the number of reviews behind it. It holds 9.4 out of 10 from 79 reviews. At about $499 a night in the August 2026 snapshot it sits in the upper part of that set, against a $247 median. The clearest reason to shortlist it is travelers who want a spa.
Its 9.4 score sits at or above the 8.8 median of this shortlist, across 79 reviews.
It is one of the more expensive options here: about $499 against a $247 median for this shortlist.
Location
The address is 81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, United States.
The honest comparison
Right for you or not
- anyone for whom a pool is part of the decision, which is rare in this city
- It is one of the more expensive options here: about $499 against a $247 median for this shortlist.
- Budget is the binding constraint: cheaper options with comparable review records exist in the Montauk / Hamptons area.
What the listing records
Facilities in the source listing
Recorded without a verification flag.
- Spa
- Fitness room
- Bar
- Restaurant
- Terrace
- Children welcome
Recorded but not verified by us. These flags most often move a booking decision, so confirm them with the hotel before they decide yours.
- Pool
- Travel Proud listing
FAQ
Common questions
Is The Pridwin Hotel a good choice?
It depends on the trip. On our weighted review measure it ranks 7 of 59 in the Montauk / Hamptons area. The main trade-off is that it is one of the more expensive options here: about $499 against a $247 median for this shortlist.
What does it cost?
About $499 a night in our August 2026 snapshot, which is a reference point rather than a bookable rate.
Are the listed facilities confirmed?
Not by us. The source listing recorded pool, travel proud listing at the time of the snapshot. Confirm anything that would decide your booking directly with the hotel.